logo

44 pages 1 hour read

How the Irish Saved Civilization: The Untold Story of Ireland's Heroic Role from the Fall of Rome to the Rise of Medieval Europe

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 1995

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapter 4Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 4 Summary: “Good News from Far Off: The First Missionary”

Patricius (Patrick) was kidnapped from Romano-British society and forced into enslaved service as a shepherd toiling under a local chieftain called Miliucc. Isolated in the hills with his herds, Patrick took refuge in his Christianity. He escaped his enslavement to devote his life to religion after receiving a divine vision. He fled Ireland on a ship headed for Gaul, arriving around 407 CE, when the former Roman province was largely “deserted,” except for some newly-arrived Germanic-speaking peoples (104).

His Irish companions struggled to find resources in Gaul, prompting them to heed Patrick’s advice to pray to the Christian God, who would provide substance. Shortly thereafter, a herd of pigs appeared. Within a few years, Patrick returned home to Britain but was restless and unsettled. After a vision in which he was called to become a “voice” to the Irish, he embarked on his mission, despite his family's resistance.

First, Patrick made his way to Gaul to acquire the necessary religious education that his enslavement hindered. He was eventually consecrated as a deacon and then a priest before finally being ordained as a bishop. Cahill describes him as “the first missionary bishop in history” (107). Patrick followed in the apostle Paul’s footsteps, as Paul also claimed a divine mission inspired by a vision, and he filled a need for missionaries that had existed since Paul’s first-century travels. Patrick was unique, however, as “the first missionary to barbarians beyond the reach of Roman law” (108). He loved the Irish, and his writings show that he “bec[a]me an Irishman” (109).

Patrick was responsible for the foundation of bishoprics across Ireland, drawing on models he encountered while on the Continent. He was like St. Augustine of Hippo in many ways but differed from his forefather in that classical urban culture did not influence him. Instead, "Patrick hoped to keep an eye on the most powerful raiders and rustlers and limit their depredations” (110).

He managed to bring the Irish slave trade to an end and composed an extant letter begging a Briton chieftain to free Irish Christians who were captured in a coastal raid. This letter shows that Patrick was no longer a Romano-Briton, because the Romanized Britons treated “Christian” and “Roman” as synonymous. Their enslavement of Irish Christians shows that they did not think of these people “as full-fledged Christians or as human beings—because they were not Roman” (112).

His fellow Britons failed to understand Patrick as the Irish did: “In becoming an Irishman, Patrick wedded his world to theirs, his faith to their life” (115). Cahill writes that Patrick rivals Augustine as a theologian because of his “emotional grasp of Christian truth” (115). This is epitomized in the vernacular prayer “St. Patrick’s Breastplate,” which is characteristically medieval and Irish in tone.

Chapter 4 Analysis

Patricius, or St. Patrick, is the hero of Cahill’s fourth chapter. This former enslaved shepherd, a Romano-Briton in name and background but an Irishman at heart, according to Cahill, single-handedly transformed Irish society. This bold and controversial assertion hinges mostly on two pieces of primary source evidence: Patrick’s Confession (Confessio) and his letter to a Briton chieftain who was responsible for enslaving Irish Christians.

Cahill does not question these texts' authenticity or interrogate their literary nature in the chapter. Rather, he saves his discussion of the scholarship on Patrick for an appendix in which he prioritizes mythos over scholarship or historical verification of details: "But none of these [scholarly] problems can cast any shadow on Patrick’s essential character, which shines [...] There is also much speculation as to the actual (as opposed to legendary) effect of his mission" (225). For Cahill, Patrick was a real historical figure of admirable character who is responsible for the conversion of the Irish. Cahill also admits to avoiding the problem of Patrick by omitting discussion of the bishop Palladius, who was sent by the papacy to missionize in Ireland before Patrick; Cahill sees his impact as insignificant.

The author frequently romanticizes Patrick. He extrapolates emotions from the Confessio, even arguing that Patrick rejected his Romano-Briton identity and saw himself as Irish. It is possible that elements of Patrick’s Confessio draw on literary tropes from early Christian hagiography—the idealized versions of the lives of saints. For example, in the text, Patrick’s family opposes his mission to Ireland and begs him never to leave home again after his escape from enslavement. He is, nevertheless, divinely inspired to undertake his mission. This story mirrors a common element of hagiographies: The saints' family members frequently oppose their Christianity or their desire to devote their lives to God. Patrick’s divine inspiration for his apostolic mission also mirrors the experience of St. Paul, who was responsible for significant numbers of conversions to Christianity across the Roman Empire. Though Cahill acknowledges the parallel, he applies little critical analysis to the sources. He accepts Patrick’s story as purely historical rather than as a blend of history and Christian literary tradition.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 44 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools