logo

46 pages 1 hour read

Cosmos

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 1980

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

The Juxtaposition of Science and Religion

It might be surprising to learn that Cosmos—a comprehensive text about how science has led to a greater understanding of the Earth and worlds beyond—is also very concerned with how various religions view of this world, which may not turn out to be the only one to support life. Interestingly, many faiths echo some of the discoveries made by scientific exploration over the last millennia. Each Cosmos chapter begins with quotations from some of the most significant religious texts from many traditions, including the Bible, the Popol Vuh from Mayan culture, the Hindu scripture Bhagavad Gita, and the Chinese philosophical tract Tao Te Ching—not to mention many literary traditions. As the author takes his audience on an interstellar voyage, he also takes them on a journey through the evolution of scientific inquiry and religious understanding—and how these two very different enterprises can actually work together to create a more expansive view of the universe.

The importance of religion becomes immediately clear. The author sees religious belief as the repository of human culture, which Sagan identifies as necessarily unified when viewed through a cosmic lens: “we are one species” (332), the only intelligent one that can claim to come from Earth. Moreover, various views of the cosmos come from the wisdom of ancient societies and embedded systems of belief. For example, The Mahapurana, a Jain text, suggests something similar to the law of conservation of energy: “Know that the world is uncreated, as time itself is, without beginning and end. And it is based on the principles” (245). This seems prescient to modern understanding of the laws of physics and to Einstein’s ideas that time and space are inextricably linked.

At the same time, Sagan emphasizes the significance of the scientific revolution and where it has led humanity: “We can do science, and with it we can improve our lives” (46). Without the advancements encouraged by Galileo, Kepler, Newton, and others, it would be impossible to explore space. Still, even these giants of scientific innovation recognized the importance of cultural continuity. For example, Newton saw no conflict between faith and science: “God is able to create particles of matter of several sizes and figures [. . .] and make worlds of several sorts in several parts of the Universe. At least, I see nothing of contradiction in all this” (217). While the scientific revolution brought about the capacity for understanding the nature of the universe in a revolutionary way—if humanity is to understand messages from an alien society, it will be through the “common language [of] science and mathematics” (296)—Sagan argues that to value science, we do not need to sacrifice the traditions that have defined us.

Did someone create the universe? Does it have a clear beginning? Is it headed for a clear end? These are questions that the author cannot and does not answer. Neither can his readers. Instead, he asks his audience to think about the importance of human culture and the relevance of scientific development. He argues that attempts to reach out across the universe to make new discoveries are crucial whether or not they succeed: “Many, perhaps most, of our messages will be indecipherable. But we have sent them because it is important to try” (287). It could be said that it is equally important to try to understand the twin heritages of human history, a belief in culture and a desire for discovery.

Where in the Cosmos Do We Belong

In part, the project of Cosmos is to define what life on Earth signifies—are humans the only intelligent species in the galaxy?—and where Earth belongs in the greater order of the cosmos. Are the assumptions about the distinctiveness of humanity accurate? The author begins the book by detailing the smallness of the planet humanity calls home; the cosmos itself is so much larger, and the significance of human existence so much smaller than once imagined. The author implicitly argues that his audience might reconsider—just as Copernicus and Galileo once did—the Earth’s and humanity’s centrality to the larger cosmos.

Sagan points to evolution as one of the most significant determinants of life on Earth—and, most likely, of life on other planets, should that be discovered. He also clarifies that if explorations are limited to life on Earth, then discoveries will also be narrow: “As long as our inquiries are limited to one or two evolutionary lines on a single planet, we will remain forever ignorant of the possible range and brilliance of other intelligences and other civilizations” (284). That is, without the experience of the cosmos, humanity will not be able to imagine the full range and possibility of life on other planets. This would constrain humanity’s ability to imagine its place in the larger universe, as well.

Sagan repeatedly emphasizes humanity’s impulse for exploration and the practice of science, which drives us always towards the unknown: “Today we are again seeking messages from an ancient and exotic civilization, this time hidden from us not only in time but also in space” (296). Sagan here uses the deciphering of ancient hieroglyphics on the Rosetta Stone as a metaphor for how humanity might converse with civilizations from other planets and/or galaxies. This impulse is what makes the pursuit of science so significant. As Christiaan Huygens characterized it, “The world is my country [. . .] science my religion” (143). Again, this speaks to the cross-pollination that the author continually recognizes between the development of human culture and human advancement.

Finally, Sagan emphasizes the connection that all of humanity has with the larger cosmos: “We are made of star stuff” (233). That is, the components of biological development and the evolution of life on the planet Earth have been made possible by the same elemental components that make up the birth of stars. Humanity cannot be separated from the cosmos, “For we are the local embodiment of the Cosmos grown to self-awareness” (345). The title of the last chapter of the book asks, “Who Speaks for Earth?”, and the author answers: “We speak for Earth” (345). Humanity’s place in the cosmos is self-evident.

The Consequences of Human Impact

In the face of the vastness and variety of the Cosmos, humanity should be humbled into examining our impact on our unique planet, Earth. The evolution of life on this planet has inevitably been affected by human desires. In addition, the continuation of life on Earth is inevitably influenced by human actions; events such as mass extinctions, climate change, and geopolitical conflict are the direct result of human decisions. There are consequences—both local and cosmological—for how humanity determines to interact with the Earth, with the larger universe, and with its own species. In the end, Sagan provides a message of hope for the future.

Sagan explains how human choices affect other creatures through a succinct example. Japanese legend holds that Heike warriors, decimated by a rival samurai group, wander the bottom of the ocean as crabs, identifiable by a specific pattern on the crab shell. Although “The Heike almost vanished from history,” because some crabs have carapaces “that disturbingly resemble the face of a samurai” (25), they have been preserved—not eaten, but thrown back to thrive in the sea. In this way, humans have changed crab evolution and this ecosystem: One type of crab thrives because humans decided that they resemble other humans; by the process of artificial selection, we directly control their environment.

Human expansion into the environment and the advancement of technology have negative impacts. Sagan addresses climate change long before the topic’s political prominence: “we have also been perturbing the climate in the opposite sense. For hundreds of thousands of years human beings have been burning and cutting down forests and encouraging domestic animals to graze on and destroy grasslands” (103). He is also clear that the geopolitical state of the Earth leaves much to be desired. From the burning of the great library of Alexandria to the Cold War, humanity has revealed a desire for destruction and chaos for the benefit of nation-states or systemic belief systems. During the writing of Cosmos, the most pervasively worrying problem was the possibility for nuclear war: “Every major power has some widely publicized justification for its procurement and stockpiling of weapons of mass destruction, often including a reptilian reminder of the presumed character and potential defects of potential enemies” (329). Sagan often reminds his readers that they are, actually, “one species” (332), hoping to significant curb the most destructive impulses that fuel the decimation of the environment and the possibilities for widespread, inevitably devastating warfare.

Sagan emphasizes that there is always hope for a better, more peaceful future, wherein scientific endeavors keep the Earth connected to the larger cosmos. First, humanity has a responsibility to continue to explore the universe, which cannot be done in the face of nuclear warfare or environmental destruction. He implores his readers to consider that, even if intelligent life is found elsewhere in the cosmos, “There will be no humans elsewhere. Only here” (339). Humanity is unique to the universe, he suggests, and thus has intrinsic value. Further, he appeals to his audience to call upon their best sensibilities: “If we survive, our time will be famous for two reasons: that at this dangerous moment of technological adolescence we managed to avoid self-destruction; and because this is the epoch in which we began our journey to the stars” (339). What better reason to preserve humanity than such a magnificent journey?

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 46 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools