61 pages • 2 hours read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
India’s caste system organizes socioeconomic classes, or castes, into a hierarchy. This system has existed for millennia and, though it has undergone various changes relating to its legality over time, societal prejudices against the lower castes persist. The caste system has its roots in Hinduism, and most castes correspond to a part of the body of Brahma, the God of creation. This suggests that all castes are necessary for society to function; however, the Dalits aren’t associated with a body part even though they do important work. Also, not all castes are treated or valued equally even though people of all castes do important jobs to contribute to the collective. Each caste is associated with a certain income level and specific job types as well as societal privileges.
The highest caste is the Brahmin (which, as the highest class, has a name resembling Brahma), in which people have professions similar to teachers and priests in that they lead society in spiritual or educational ways. The Brahmin caste is associated with Brahma’s head because of their educational function. The next caste is the Kshatriya, in which people have professions that help protect society and lead it in logical ways, like politicians and soldiers. The Kshatriya caste is associated with Brahma’s shoulders. Next is the Vaishya caste, which contains merchants, farmers, and people in other professions who produce or sell goods that society needs. The Vaishya caste is associated with Brahma’s legs. Next is the Shudra caste, in which people are manual laborers who do the jobs that keep society moving. The Shudra caste is associated with Brahma’s feet. The lowest caste, which isn’t associated with any part of Brahma, is the Dalit caste, in which people work as janitors, street cleaners, and other roles to generally clean up after society. People of other classes generally consider those of the Dalit caste “outcaste” or “untouchable” even though their work is immensely valuable to society.
The caste system is based on Hindu scripture, which makes it ingrained in the social consciousness despite changes in legal meanings. Taboos against marrying outside one’s caste or hiring someone of a lower caste has created difficulties in achieving “upward mobility,” or transcending the caste into which one is born. Legal measures have reduced caste-based segregation and prejudice, and the enactment of government quotas has aimed to help people of lower castes get higher-paying leadership jobs. However, as Born Behind Bars suggests, enforcing such laws is challenging, often more so than enforcing antidiscrimination laws in the US, so persistent caste-based prejudice still haunts the lives of many.
In Born Behind Bars, Kabir and Amma are Dalits, which creates significant obstacles that they nonetheless find the strength to overcome. Amma is imprisoned wholly because of her caste: She was accused of theft due to stereotypes and, although she was innocent, couldn’t afford bail or a lawyer for a trial. Therefore, she served a decade of prison time for a crime she never committed. Upon Kabir’s release from prison, where he was born, he realizes how intense caste-based prejudice is out in the world. Most people ignore him completely, calling him “untouchable.” The authorities give him to human traffickers because they don’t care enough to double-check who is picking him up from prison. People even threaten him with violence just because he’s in the same area as them. Some of this prejudicial behavior is illegal yet still frequently occurs.
In India, children of women who are incarcerated can stay with their mothers in prison until age six if no family is available to care for them and no other suitable alternatives exist. This typically requires a discussion of options, but some mothers opt for this because, as Amma in Born Behind Bars remarks, an orphanage isn’t a promising alternative.
Although this arrangement allows children to spend more time with their mothers, it’s also controversial because the children end up being “punished” in some of the same ways as incarcerated adults, although these children aren’t convicted criminals. For example, the children must remain in the prison and live in guarded cells, with limited access to basic privileges that civilians enjoy. Not all prisons have schoolrooms like the prison Kabir was in, and they don’t all have suitable food or access to medical care either. Although some basic necessities are legally required, this doesn’t ensure their implementation, just as in Born Behind Bars the prison has neglected to observe the age limit in Kabir’s case. According to IndiaSpend, in 2019, 1,779 children lived in Indian women’s prisons (Paliath, Shreehari. “Living with Imprisoned Mothers, Children Struggle for Normal Childhood.” IndiaSpend, 6 Oct. 2020). This number shifts constantly based on who is incarcerated and what ages their children are.
Born Behind Bars illustrates some of the problems with the policy of allowing young children to be raised in prisons that weren’t built for them and lack the resources to support healthy development. Kabir can’t attend an adequate school and doesn’t get adequate food, nor is he socialized with other kids his own age or taught how to exist in the outside world. This puts him at a great disadvantage upon his release (into the hands of human traffickers, because the police don’t take the time to ensure that the man picking him up from the prison is truly family). The novel depicts an extreme level of disregard for legal and ethical conduct, suggesting that authorities consistently follow few laws concerning prisons. They allow Kabir to stay in the prison for three extra years and then release him to human traffickers. In addition, they hold Amma far longer than her maximum sentence (and she’s in prison solely because of systemic prejudice and possibly upper-caste privilege, having not committed any crime). Kabir miraculously survives and even thrives in the outside world in spite of, not because of, his experience of being raised in prison. Amma is a great mother but, being incarcerated, can’t raise her child the way she may have wanted and doesn’t view the prison as a “home” despite their being together there.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Padma Venkatraman
Action & Adventure Reads (Middle Grade)
View Collection
Asian American & Pacific Islander...
View Collection
Books that Teach Empathy
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Community
View Collection
Contemporary Books on Social Justice
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Indian Literature
View Collection
Juvenile Literature
View Collection
Nation & Nationalism
View Collection
Politics & Government
View Collection
Poverty & Homelessness
View Collection
Realistic Fiction (Middle Grade)
View Collection
School Book List Titles
View Collection
The Journey
View Collection
Valentine's Day Reads: The Theme of Love
View Collection